Real vs. Fake Christmas Trees...Which Should You Choose?
Posted on December 6, 2024
When it comes to sustainability during
the holidays, one question often stands out for folks who celebrate Christmas: Should you buy a real tree or an artificial one? Like most things in life, the answer to that
question isn’t as straightforward as you might think—it depends on several
factors, including how you use and dispose of your tree. Let’s break it
down!
Artificial
Trees
Artificial Christmas trees are usually made of plastic and
are often manufactured overseas, meaning they come with a hefty carbon
footprint before they even reach your living room. On the plus side, they can
be reused for many years. However, research suggests you’d need to keep an
artificial tree for anywhere from 5 to 20 years to offset the environmental
impact.
Real
Trees
The idea of cutting a tree down once a year (or even just
once!) might feel crazy. But, “the chop” can come
with surprising environmental benefits.
Think about it: Christmas trees are typically grown on tree farms, not
harvested from forests. These trees wouldn’t exist at all if not for Christmas
tree farmers. Like any real tree, the trees on tree farms create habitat for
wildlife, absorb carbon dioxide, and emit oxygen. Plus, real trees are
biodegradable and can be composted, turned into mulch, or used for other
eco-friendly purposes. And, if you buy local, you’ll be supporting a
local farmer.
The Complications
If you have to drive a considerable distance to get to a Christmas tree
farm, the carbon emissions from your vehicle can outweigh the benefits of
buying a real tree. And, depending on where you’re located, you might run the
risk of bringing home invasive insects.
Okay...so then what!? Well, if you don't plan on moving closer to a Christmas tree farm or downsizing, it's perfectly fine to buy an artificial tree and keep it for several years. As an alternative, try to purchase a gently used tree...or commit to a new house plant and decorate
that instead!
The
Verdict
If you’re looking for the most sustainable option, real trees are the
greener choice—but only if they’re responsibly sourced and properly disposed
of. Choose a tree from a local farm or a certified sustainable grower to
minimize transportation emissions. Once the holidays are over, recycle your
tree at a designated drop-off location or repurpose it in your yard.
For those who already own an artificial
tree, the best thing you can do is keep using it for as long as possible. Avoid
discarding it unless absolutely necessary. And if you need to get rid of
it, consider donating it.
Ultimately, whether you choose a real or
fake tree, being mindful of your decision and how it impacts the environment means
that you're on the right track!
